Skip to main content
Recruiting

The 5 Metrics That Reveal Your Recruiting Process Is Broken (And How to Fix Them) 

 

Is your recruiting process actually working — or just “kind of working”? If you’ve ever felt like you’re spinning your wheels trying to attract talent, you’re not alone. 

The truth is, most companies don’t realize their recruiting process is broken until they’re knee-deep in unfilled roles, ghosted interviews, and spiraling costs. But the red flags are there — and they show up in your data. 

Here are 5 key metrics that reveal when your recruiting process isn’t just inefficient… it’s broken. 

  1. Time-to-Hire Is Over 30 Days (And Getting Longer)

If your time-to-hire is stretching beyond 30–45 days, you’re already behind.
Why it matters: 

  • Top candidates are off the market in just 10–14 days 
  • Every day an open role goes unfilled costs you in productivity and revenue 
  • Delays lead to drop-off, ghosting, and frustration — for both candidates and hiring managers 

📉 Fix it with: a streamlined interview process, pre-qualified candidate pipelines, or a recruiting partner who can fast-track the right talent. 

 

  1. Offer Acceptance Rate Below 80%

You’ve finally found “the one,” but they ghost or decline your offer. Sound familiar?
Why it matters: 

  • A low offer acceptance rate signals deeper problems: slow process, bad candidate experience, or noncompetitive comp 
  • Every declined offer resets the clock and demoralizes your team 

📉 Fix it with: compensation benchmarking, candidate engagement touchpoints, and better offer staging. 

 

  1. Candidate Drop-Off Rate Over 40%

If nearly half of your qualified applicants are disappearing mid-process, something’s wrong.
Why it matters: 

  • Complex, impersonal, or slow processes push candidates away 
  • 60% of job seekers abandon applications that are too long 
  • 1 in 3 drop off during clunky interview scheduling alone 

📉 Fix it with: optimized application flows, consistent candidate communication, and scheduling support from experienced recruiters. 

 

  1. Too Many “Unqualified” Applicants per Role

Many companies in today’s market are telling us they don’t need recruiting help because they have hundreds of applicants to sort through. If your inbox is full of résumés that don’t match the job, the issue may be time, job description, and process.
Why it matters: 

  • Vague job descriptions, poor targeting, or wrong channels waste everyone’s time 
  • Not enough knock out questions 
  • Your recruiters spend more time filtering than interviewing 

📉 Fix it with: professionally written job postings, smarter sourcing, and data-backed targeting tools like our in-house ATS (Gatekeeper). 

 

  1. Your Team Is Burned Out

Overwhelmed HR and recruiting teams = inconsistent candidate experience = missed hires.
Why it matters: 

  • Burnout leads to mistakes, delays, and disengaged stakeholders 
  • If you’re short-staffed or stretched thin, recruiting becomes reactive — not strategic 

📉 Fix it with: Recruitment Process Outsourcing (RPO), fractional recruiter support (RSO), or simply borrowing our team for your open roles monthly without any long-term contracts. 

 

Conclusion: 

If any of these metrics hit home, it’s not just a recruiting hiccup — it’s a signal your process needs attention, and your company may be missing out on strong talent. 

The good news? You don’t have to fix it alone. 

At HRmango, we help companies like yours streamline recruiting, reduce costs, and get the right talent — faster. Whether you need full-cycle recruiting, support for your internal team, or just want to use our ATS GateKeeper, we’ve got you. 

Share